Surviving
Death/Alive Why?
by Larval
2007, Cuneiform Records, $18 US
Distributors website: http://www.cuneiformrecords.com
Reviewed by Michael R. (Mike) Mosher
Saginaw Valley State University
mosher@svsu.edu
This reviewer paid particular attention
to what was most characteristic of Detroit
rock traditions to be found in the recent
instrumental music of Bill Brovold and
his band Larval. To begin with the package,
the band's double album Surviving Death/Alive
Why? sports a cover by Mark Dancey
(http://www.illuminado.com). Yet it is
not one of Dancey's outlandish "Clown
Skull" cartoon graphics that have promoted
other Detroit bands; the painting is one
of Dancey's classical oil tondos of nude
aerialist women. This is fitting, for
Larval often distances itself from the
skronk and screech and ka-chunk of many
of that city's bands, from the MC5 and
Stooges, to the White Stripes and Dirtbombs.
Beside all that raw energy, there existed
a more trained, virtuoso tradition in
the region too, in bands like Savage Grace
and SRC (who medlied Grieg's "Hall of
the Mountain King" with Ravel's "Bolero"),
cerebrally worthy of a record cover like
Larval's as teasingpeekaboo!as
Fragonard's "Girl on a Swing". Despite
an ocean between them, there was only
a short aesthetic distance between Steve
McKay's fierce sax in Earth Opera and
the Stooges' Fun House, and Andy MacKay's
learned reeds in Roxy Music.
On the first disc, called Surviving
Death, "Scottish Blood" strums chords
reminiscent of Sufjan Stevens' songs of
Michigan, yet the title song "Surviving
Death" has the ominous biting guitar of
Pink Floyd's Ummagumma. "The Hospital
Visit" has deep lonely piano chords, while
the wordless variety show of "The 300
Pound Nurse" seemingly includes a Spy-vs.-Spy
segment. "It Was a Puny Plan" manifests
big rock themes atop 1970s drum fills,
and postmodern Bowie melancholy. It's
reminiscent of M3, the work done by Michigan-raised
Roger Miller with brothers Ben and Larry,
abrupt switching of time signatures and
that Beefhearty saxophone that Ben honked
with Destroy All Monsters three decades
ago. On Larval's second disc, the live
album Alive Why?, "Alpha Thejone"
has transformative time signatures and
stop-time, characteristic of M3.
What could be more Detroit than a live
album? Detroit bands the MC5 and Commander
Cody & the Lost Planet Airmen recorded
live albums as their first albums when
the prevailing tradition of the time was
to precede the concert document with three
or four studio albums. Alive Why?
includes tracks recorded by Larval in
1999 to 2001, and then 2006. On "One Step
Forward", Kurt Zimmerman saws away on
scary violin until the tune groans into
Led Zeppelin gravitas. In the late 1960s,
a staple of Detroit's WABX-FM was "White
Bird" by the California band It's a Beautiful
Day, with violinist David LaFlamme. Another
current Detroit band, Tone and Niche (http://www.toneandniche.com),
features violinist Nicole Varga.
"Crippled Dance" is grindingly repetitive,
as were the Stooges at their most irritating
and hypnotic. "Childish Delusions" and
"Last Ditch" have a slouching, smoldering
atonal insistence and angularity. The
saxophone of "Last Ditch" is a distant
air raid siren, promoting rock-drill-to-the-head
anxiety, soothed by swirly guitar lines.
"Guitar Trio" features strumming rock
guitars that can't forget the Motor City.