Leonardo Digital Reviews
 LDR Home  Index/Search  Leonardo On-Line  About Leonardo  Whats New








Reviewer Biography

LDR Category List

Books

CDs

Events/Exhibits

Film/Video

Ptolemy's Geography: An Annotated Translation of the Theoretical Chapters

By J. Lennart Berggren and Alexander Jones.
Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 2001.
232 pp., illus.
Trade, $39.50 US.
ISBN: 0-691-01042-0.
Reviewed by David Topper, The University of Winnipeg, Winnipeg, MB R3B 2E9 Canada. E-mail: Topper@Uwinnipeg.ca


Ptolemy's Cosmographica (Geography), without a doubt, is a landmark in the history of cartography, one of the Great Books (if we may still use the term) in the Western canon of Science. For over 1400 years it constituted the major map of the Western world. Yet there has not been an adequate translation into English, till now. Scholars of ancient history and science are praising this translation, which drew upon several previous editions and five medieval manuscripts.

Written in the second century of our era, Ptolemy's Geography is the only ancient work on map-making to survive. It was based on a previous work by Marinos of Tyre, about whom little is known, so that most of the prehistory of Ptolemy's book involves mere speculation. The work (first written as a scroll) was known throughout the Middle Ages. The earliest extant manuscripts date from the 13th century. There are about 50 manuscripts, and all seem to descend from one (lost) prototype.

Ptolemy divided the Geography into eight sections ("Books"). It contained the first systematic listing of latitude and longitude. (These now common terrestrial terms were first applied to the celestial "globe" of the heavens.) The resulting map of about 8000 locations entailed about _ of the surface of the earth, from Western Europe to South East Asia (approximately 180 degrees of longitude) and from Scotland to sub-Sahara Africa (approximately 90 degrees of latitude). The Roman Empire, not surprisingly, was best known. Ptolemy used two projection techniques to create visual maps: for one the longitudinal lines remained straight, and for the other both longitude and latitude were curved; in the second he tried to minimize some of the distortions from the first. In addition to these two "world" maps, there are 26 regional maps. Of course by today's standard, the distortions of the maps are not due primary to the methods of projection but to the errors in position of the specific locations, especially as they get further from the Mediterranean region.

In this important edition the authors have translated only the "theoretical parts" (Books 1,2,7, & 8), thus eliminating the lengthy lists of places. They did this to shift attention away from topography to the theory and methodology of map-making. It begins with a long introductory section of over 50 pages. Here the reader is grounded in fundamental geometrical information and projection techniques required for fully comprehending the maps. Historical background material on the work and the history of the manuscript versions and the translations are likewise presented. Following the four translated Books of the Geography (the core of this edition) are a series of plates and maps and eight appendices. Several plates are wonderful color reproductions of the "world" maps. Many of the maps portray sections of Ptolemy's version and juxtapose these with present-day projections of the same sections - a most interesting comparison.

This is an important publication for historians of science (especially of cartography) and classicists. Although the novice reader will enjoy perusing the plates and maps and certainly gain from some of the early introductory material, but most of the rest of this edition is directed primarily to the advanced scholar.

top







Updated 5 July 2001.




Contact LDR: ldr@leonardo.org

Contact Leonardo: isast@leonardo.info


copyright © 2001 ISAST