Problem
Solved: A Primer in Design and Communication
by Michael
Johnson
Phaidon Press, New York NY, 2004
288 pp., illus. 150 b/w, 500 col. Trade,
$49.95; paper, $29.95
ISBN: 0-7148-4174-9; ISBN: 0-7148-4453-5.
Reviewed by Roy R. Behrens
Department of Art, University of Northern
Iowa, USA
ballast@netins.net
In the U.S.,
where art schools are often a mixture
of artists and designers, the former are
typically said to "create" works of art
while the latter are apt to more modestly
claim that they only "solve problems."
To put it another way (as does this book's
author), "[while] a fine art student can
get away with creating his or her own
problems to solve, a communications student
is usually handed someone else's, with
a looming deadline thrown in." It is itself
a problem that designers always have to
deal with limitations of time, function,
budget, style and print production, and
it leads to unending discussions about
whether or not it would help to compile
a typology (a comprehensive directory)
of kinds of problems, and, having done
so, to identify trustworthy, time-saving
means to address those problems. Among
the best-known books on this subject is
Forget All the Rules You Ever Learned
About Graphic Design (1981), by Bob
Gill, whose influence is acknowledged
in the introduction to this book. Of related
significance are books by Edward de Bono
(not mentioned here), who wrote interminably
about what he called "lateral thinking";
A Smile in the Mind by Beryl McAlhone
and David Stuart (1996); and, most recently,
The Art of Looking Sideways by
Alan Fletcher (2001).
This book by a British designer who is
Creative Director of Johnson Banks is
the paperbound edition of a title that
was first released by Phaidon in 2002.
Given the excellence and extraordinary
number of its illustrations, as well as
its vigorous, literate tone, it is a deserving
addition to the always ongoing debate
in design about how to arrive at proposals
that are both unexpected and appropriate.
There are eighteen sections in this book,
each given to a certain kind of communication
problem, the point of which is summed
up by a memorable heading that (consistent
with the samples shown) is both surprising
and suitable. There are, for example,
sections that play up such themes as evolution
versus revolution, doing more while using
less, making fresh use of historical styles,
finding legitimate ways to resolve ethical
imbroglios, effectively designing
for education, and so on. With each turn
of the page, one encounters the finest
examples of wit (ranging from hilarious
to offensive), such as the political billboard
of a pregnant Tony Blair that reads "Four
Years of Labour and He Still Hasn't Delivered";
or a book of short stories by Vladimir
Nabokov (who was not only a writer but
a prominent butterfly expert as well)
in which the letters of his name on the
cover are mounted on pins in a butterfly
case; or a recent ad for Volkswagen in
which three of the redesigned Beetles
appear to be feeding like piglets at the
chassis of an older van.
(Reprinted by permission from Ballast
Quarterly Review, Vol. 20, No. 1,
Autumn 2004.)